Air Navigation Regulations (Amendment) 1992 No. 104
EXPLANATORY STATEMENT
STATUTORY RULES 1992 No. 104
Issued by the authority of the Minister for the Arts, Sport, the Environment and Territories for, and on behalf of the Minister tor Shipping and Aviation
Air Navigation Act 1920
Air Navigation Regulations (Amendment)
Sub-section 26(1) of the Air Navigation Act 1920 provides that the Governor-General may make regulations for the purposes of the Act.
Australia has an international legal obligation to comply with united Nations Security Council Resolutions. Air Navigation Regulation 311D gave affect to Security Council Resolution 670 (1990) which required all States to deny permission to aircraft flying to or from Iraq to take off from, land in or overfly their territory. Subregulations 311D(4), (5) and (6) specify the conditions under which the Secretary can approve an aircraft to travel to or from Iraq.
To obviate the necessity to continually amend Regulation 311D In response to further Security Council Resolutions the amendments omit subregulations 311D(4), (5) and (6) and substitute a new subregulation (4) which provides that In deciding whether to give approval the Secretary must take into account Australia's relations with other Countries and its obligations under international law.
The amendments also implement Security Council Resolution 748 (1992), adopted on 1 April 1992. That Resolution requires all States to deny permission to any aircraft to take oft from, land in or overfly their territory if it is destined to land in or has taken off from the territory of Libya, unless the particular flight has been approved on grounds of urgent humanitarian need by the Committee established by clause 9 of the Resolution.
The amendments to the Air Navigation Regulations implement Resolution 749 (1992) by providing:
- an Australian aircraft must not travel to or from Libya without the express approval of the Secretary;
- an aircraft that, after the commencement of this regulation, leaves Libyan territory or is destined to land in Libyan territory must not be landed in, flown over or flown from, Australian territory without the express approval of the secretary.
In deciding whether to give approval the Secretary must take into account Australia's relations with other countries and its obligations under international law. This formulation ensures that the requirements of the Resolution are met and obviates the necessity of further amending the Regulations if further security Council Resolutions amend the conditions governing flights to and from Libya.
No provision is made for review on the merits of decisions made pursuant to the amendments. Review on the merits is not considered appropriate because the decisions made under the amendments are for the purpose of fulfilling Australia's International obligations and because of the effect on Australia's relations with other countries.
Overview
The Air Navigation Regulations (Amendment) 1992 No. 104 were introduced to address Australia's compliance with United Nations Security Council Resolutions, particularly resolutions 670 (1990) and 748 (1992). These resolutions mandated that all states, including Australia, must deny permission for aircraft to take off from, land in, or overfly their territories if they are flying to or from Iraq and Libya, unless approved under specific conditions. Enacted by the Minister for the Arts, Sport, the Environment and Territories on behalf of the Minister for Shipping and Aviation, these amendments to the Air Navigation Act 1920 were intended to streamline Australia's regulatory framework in response to international mandates, ensuring that the country's obligations under international law are met. By replacing specific subregulations with a broader criterion for the Secretary's approval, the amendments aim to simplify future compliance with any further resolutions issued by the United Nations Security Council.
Scope and Application
The Air Navigation Regulations (Amendment) 1992 No. 104 applies to all aircraft, both Australian and foreign, intending to fly to or from Iraq and Libya. The amendments are made to ensure compliance with the United Nations Security Council Resolutions 670 and 748. These amendments apply nationally across Australia and are made under the authority of the Air Navigation Act 1920, which empowers the Governor-General to make regulations for the purposes of the Act. The amendments omit specific subregulations and substitute a new subregulation that requires the Secretary to consider Australia's international relations and obligations when deciding whether to give approval for flights to or from Iraq and Libya. This change is intended to streamline future amendments in response to new Security Council Resolutions. The amendments do not provide for a review on the merits of the Secretary's decisions, as such review is deemed inappropriate given the international obligations and diplomatic considerations involved.
Key Provisions
The main operative sections of the Air Navigation Regulations (Amendment) 1992 (No. 104) primarily focus on updating the regulatory framework to comply with recent United Nations Security Council Resolutions. Specifically, sub-section 26(1) of the Air Navigation Act 1920 allows the Governor-General to make regulations for the purposes of the Act. The amendments to Regulation 311D replace the previous conditions for approving flights to and from Iraq and Libya with a more flexible framework (subregulation 311D(4)) that mandates the Secretary to consider Australia's international relations and obligations under international law when granting approvals. This ensures compliance with Security Council Resolutions 670 (1990) and 748 (1992). The new provisions also include specific requirements for flights to and from Libya, such as prohibiting travel without express approval from the Secretary and detailing the conditions for granting such approvals.
The obligations and requirements imposed by the amendments are primarily on the Secretary of the Department responsible for aviation, who must now consider Australia's diplomatic relations and international legal obligations when deciding whether to approve flights to or from Libya. This includes carefully assessing the implications of granting or denying approval based on Australia's standing with other countries and adherence to international law. The Secretary must also ensure that any approvals granted are consistent with the terms of relevant United Nations Security Council Resolutions, particularly those pertaining to Libya.
The amendments introduce several potential consequences for non-compliance. Although the regulations do not provide for a review on the merits of the Secretary's decisions, failure to comply with the requirements could result in legal and diplomatic repercussions. For instance, if an Australian aircraft travels to or from Libya without the required approval, it could lead to sanctions or other punitive measures against Australia by the international community. Furthermore, individuals or entities contravening these regulations could face civil or criminal penalties, although the exact nature and severity of these penalties are not explicitly detailed within the amendments themselves. The overarching intent is to ensure strict adherence to international obligations and to maintain Australia's compliance with United Nations directives.