MSC Consulting Group Limited v Oyster Management Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA423/2019
 [2020] NZCA 417

BETWEEN

MSC CONSULTING GROUP LIMITED
Appellant

AND

OYSTER MANAGEMENT LIMITED
First Respondent

CORINTHIAN TRUSTEES LIMITED
Second Respondent

Hearing:

9 July 2020

Court:

French, Collins and Goddard JJ

Counsel:

R M Flinn and N J Cannon for Appellant
N F Flanagan and D R Green for Respondents

Judgment:

15 September 2020 at 9 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe respondents must file in the High Court and serve an amended statement of claim which complies with the directions set out at [77] within 30 days of the date of delivery of this judgment or such other period allowed by the High Court.

C    There will be no order as to costs. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by French J)

Introduction

  1. MSC Consulting Group Ltd is facing a claim of negligent misstatement at the suit of the respondents in the High Court.  MSC is a consulting structural engineer and the claim arises out of a seismic assessment report it provided to a client who subsequently provided it to the respondents.

  2. MSC applied for summary judgment and for the claim to be struck out as disclosing no tenable cause of action.  Both applications were declined by Brewer J.[1]  MSC now appeals that decision, having first obtained the necessary leave to do so.[2]

Background

[2]Oyster Management Ltd v MSC Consulting [Group] Ltd HC Auckland CIV-2018-404-2021, 1 August 2019.

  1. The following statement of the background facts is taken from the statement of claim and the affidavit evidence that was filed in relation to the summary judgment application.

  2. In the early 2000s, MSC was engaged to assist in the design and construction of a five-storey commercial building situated in Auckland.

  3. Following construction, a company called Smales Farm Management (Smales) was responsible for managing the building on behalf of its then owner, including making arrangements for commercial customers to tenant the building.

  4. In about mid-2012, Smales engaged MSC to undertake a review of the building’s structural design, with the focus on its seismic performance.  According to the statement of claim, this was done, as a result of the Christchurch earthquakes, to reassure Smales and tenants that the building had been properly designed for a high degree of seismic performance.  The statement of claim does not expressly say this but the term “tenants” is, we understand, intended to encompass both existing and prospective tenants.

  5. The seismic performance of a building is assessed by reference to the extent to which it complies with current earthquake design levels for new buildings. At the time, a building that was less than 34 percent of the new building standard rating and likely to collapse in an earthquake causing injury or property damage was identified as “earthquake prone” under the Building Act 2004.[3]  The legal significance of a building being identified…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MSC Consulting Group Limited v Oyster Management Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZCA 417
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

MSC Consulting Group Limited is appealing a decision of Brewer J in the High Court to decline MSC's application for summary judgment and to refuse an order to strike out a claim for negligent misstatement. The claim was brought by Oyster Management Limited and Corinthian Trustees Limited against MSC in relation to a seismic assessment report MSC had prepared for a commercial building in Auckland. The High Court dismissed MSC's application and the appeal against that decision is now before the Court of Appeal. The central issue is whether MSC owed a duty of care to Oyster and Corinthian in preparing the seismic assessment report. The Court of Appeal held that while the claim has some difficulties, it is not so hopelessly bad as to justify striking it out and ordered that the respondents file an amended statement of claim within 30 days. The Court also held that the respondents' reliance on building cases such as Spencer on Byron is misplaced because the context of those cases is very different. The appeal is dismissed with no order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the early 2000s, MSC Consulting Group Ltd was engaged to assist in the design and construction of a five-storey commercial building in Auckland. Following construction, Smales Farm Management was responsible for managing the building on behalf of its owner. In mid-2012, Smales engaged MSC to review the building's structural design with a focus on its seismic performance, due to concerns raised by the Christchurch earthquakes. MSC provided Smales with an initial structural evaluation report (IEP) in May 2012, which concluded that the building had a new building standard rating of 72 percent. Because this rating was less than the 80 percent required by some major commercial and institutional entities for leasing, Smales commissioned MSC to prepare a more detailed engineering evaluation (DEE). The DEE, provided in September 2012, assessed the building as having a new building standard rating of up to 87 percent. The DEE also contained a limitation of liability clause, stating the report was for reliance by Smales and only for this commission. Smales provided copies of the DEE to prospective tenants, including ANZ bank which signed a lease in July 2014. In October 2014, Oyster Management Ltd entered into a conditional agreement to buy the building and received a copy of the DEE during due diligence. The purchase became unconditional in November 2014. Corinthian Trustees Ltd settled the purchase of the building in March 2015 as Oyster's nominee and took possession. In June 2017, ANZ commissioned another firm of engineers to review MSC's IEP and DEE, which assessed the building as a very high-risk earthquake prone building with an overall new building standard rating of less than 20 percent. MSC revised its rating from 87 percent to 23 percent. The respondents issued their proceedings against MSC in September 2018, pleading two causes of action in negligence.

MSC applied for summary judgment and for the claim to be struck out as disclosing no tenable cause of action. Both applications were declined by Brewer J in the High Court. MSC obtained the necessary leave and appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appeal was heard on 9 July 2020, and the judgment was delivered on 15 September 2020.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the circumstances of the case are capable of supporting the existence of a duty of care, as required for the tort of negligent misstatement.
2. Whether the negligent misstatement claim can proceed, given the limitation of liability clause in the DEE report.
3. Whether there are sufficient grounds to amend the statement of claim to address the objections raised by MSC.

Held
1. The court held that the circumstances of the case are capable of supporting the existence of a duty of care required for the tort of negligent misstatement. The appeal against this decision was dismissed.
2. The court held that the negligent misstatement claim can proceed, despite the limitation of liability clause in the DEE report. The clause was not clear enough to preclude liability to the respondents.
3. The court held that there are sufficient grounds to amend the statement of claim to address the objections raised by MSC. The respondents must file an amended statement of claim within 30 days of the judgment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered whether the circumstances of the case could support the existence of a duty of care for the tort of negligent misstatement. The court applied the Caparo test to determine whether there was sufficient proximity between the parties. The test involves examining whether the advice was required for a known purpose, the adviser knew their advice would be communicated to the advisee, and it was likely that the advice would be acted upon without independent inquiry. The court found that while the respondents' claim faced difficulties, it was not so hopelessly bad that it should be struck out.

The court also considered whether the limitation of liability clause in the DEE report precluded liability. The court disagreed, finding that the clause was not clear enough to effectively preclude liability to the respondents.

Lastly, the court held that there were sufficient grounds to amend the statement of claim. The court ordered the respondents to file an amended statement of claim within 30 days of the judgment, with specific directions to address the objections raised by MSC. The court considered that this outcome was preferable to striking out the claim and requiring the respondents to file a fresh statement of claim.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a duty of care may exist in cases of negligent misstatement where there is sufficient proximity between the parties, and a limitation of liability clause may not necessarily preclude liability if it is not clear enough. Additionally, the court may order an amendment to the statement of claim rather than striking it out if there are sufficient grounds to do so.