TCL Technology Group Corporation v Musco Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by TCL Technology Group Corporation to registration of trade mark application 2186036 – TLC for LED – in the name of Musco Corporation

Delegate: Bianca Irgang
Representation: Opponent: Dr Kin Leong of Madderns
Applicant: Sonia Stewart of counsel instructed by FB Rice Pty Ltd
Decision: 2023 ATMO 196
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) - Section 52 opposition – ss 44, 58A and 60 grounds of opposition considered – no grounds of opposition established – trade mark to proceed to registration.

Background

  1. Musco Corporation (‘the applicant’), filed trade mark application number 2186036  on 11 June 2021 in classes 11 and 42 of the Nice Agreement Concerning the International Classification of Goods and Services. Current details of the application are set out below.

    Trade mark:  TLC for LED (the ‘Trade Mark’)

    Trade mark application no: 2186036

    Priority Date:  11 June 2021

    Specification:  Class 11: LED luminaires for indoor and outdoor lighting applications; lighting apparatus, namely, lighting installations; lighting fixtures; LED lighting systems, namely, LED modules, power supplies, and wiring

    Class 42: Design of large area and sports facility lighting systems for others; consulting services in the field of the design of lighting systems to minimize the effects of glare on spectators and neighbours; lighting design and technology specification services pertaining to permanent or temporary architectural, theatrical, entertainment, commercial and/or residential applications

  2. Acceptance of the application for possible registration was advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks dated 12 November 2021. Subsequently, TCL Technology Group Corporation  (‘the opponent’) filed a Notice of Intention to Oppose registration followed by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’).

  3. The applicant then filed its Notice of Intention to Defend. Thereafter, the opponent and the applicant filed evidence in accordance with the provisions of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995 (Cth) (‘the Regulations’).

  4. I heard the opposition by teleconference as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks on 3 November 2023. The opponent was represented by Dr Kin Leong of Madderns. The applicant was represented Sonia Stewart of counsel instructed by FB Rice Pty Ltd.

    Grounds of Opposition

  5. The SGP nominated a number of grounds of opposition under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (‘the Act’) and sections 44, 58A and 60 were pursued at the hearing. The opponent bears the onus of establishing at least one of the grounds of opposition.[1] The standard of proof is the ordinary civil standard of the balance of probabilities.[2]

    Evidence

  6. The evidence filed in this matter consists of the following declarations being:

    Opponent’s evidence in support

    ·Declaration of Fu Chaohui, General Manager of the Legal Department…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TCL Technology Group Corporation v Musco Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ATMO 196
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

TCL Technology Group Corporation (the opponent) opposed the application by Musco Corporation (the applicant) for registration of a trade mark. The opposition was based on grounds including sections 44, 58A, and 60 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth). The hearing officer was required to determine whether any of these grounds of opposition were established.

The primary legal issue was whether the applicant's proposed trade mark was substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to, any of the opponent's registered trade marks or pending applications, in relation to similar goods or closely related services, with an earlier priority date. The opponent also raised grounds relating to misrepresentation and false attribution, but these were not pursued in detail.

The hearing officer considered the evidence filed by both parties, including declarations and exhibits. In relation to section 44, the opponent needed to demonstrate the existence of a registered or pending trade mark in its name, that the applicant's mark was substantially identical or deceptively similar to it, that the goods or services were similar or closely related, and that the opponent's priority date was earlier. After examining the opponent's six registered trade marks and the applicant's proposed mark, the hearing officer found that the opponent had not established that the applicant's trade mark was substantially identical with or deceptively similar to any of its registered marks in respect of similar goods or closely related services. Consequently, the section 44 ground of opposition failed. The other grounds of opposition were also not established.

The opposition was dismissed, and the trade mark application was allowed to proceed to registration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence filed in this matter consists of the following declarations being:Opponent’s evidence in support·Declaration of Fu Chaohui, General Manager of the Legal Department of the Opponent, dated 1 August 2022 with exhibits FC01 to FC07 (“Chaohui 1”) Applicant’s evidence in answer·Declaration of James Hansen, Company Secretary of the Applicant, dated 7 November 2022 with annexures A to F; and ·Declaration of Sanjay Prakash, Sales Executive of Musco Lighting Australia Pty Ltd, dated 8 November 2022 with annexures A to D.Opponent’s evidence in reply·Declaration of Fu Chaohui, dated 8 January 2023 with exhibits FC08 to FC10DiscussionSection 44 Section 44 of the Act relevantly provides:44 Identical etc. trade marks (1) Subject to subsections (3) and (4), an application for the registration of a trade mark (applicant’s trade mark) in respect of goods (applicant’s goods) must be rejected if: (a) the applicant’s trade mark is substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to: (i) a trade mark registered by another person in respect of similar goods or closely related services; or (ii) a trade mark whose registration in respect of similar goods or closely related services is being sought by another person; and (b) the priority date for the registration of the applicant’s trade mark in respect of the applicant’s goods is not earlier than the priority date for the registration of the other trade mark in respect of the similar goods or closely related services.(2) Subject to subsections (3) and (4), an application for the registration of a trade mark (the applicant’s trade mark) in respect of services (applicant’s services) must be rejected if:(a) it is substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to: (i) a trade mark registered by another person in respect of similar services or closely related goods; or (ii) a trade mark whose registration in respect of similar services or closely related goods is being sought by another person; and (b) the priority date for the registration of the applicant’s trade mark in respect of the applicant’s services is not earlier than the priority date for the registration of the other trade mark in respect of the similar services or closely related goods. To establish its opposition in terms of section 44 of the Act the opponent must show all of the following:·a trade mark (or trade marks), either registered or pending registration, in the name of a person other than the present applicant, and in relation to which the opposed trade mark is either substantially identical or deceptively similar;·the trade mark(s) in the name of the other person must be in respect of similar goods or closely related services; and·the priority date(s) of the other person’s trade mark(s) is (are) earlier. The opponent is the registered owner of six trade mark registrations which it has particularized in its SGP and submissions in support of the section 44 ground of opposition. I will refer to the following registrations as the ‘opponent’s trade marks’ as a collective unless otherwise specifying a particular trade mark. The details of the opponent’s trade marks are as follows: Trade mark: Trade mark no: 735264Priority Date: 12 May 1997Specification: Class 9: Sound recording tapes; video tapes; transformers; circuit boards; loudspeakers; alarms for mining; intelligent instrument meters; audio equipment; calculating machines and peripheral equipment; electronic data processing installations; copying apparatus and machines; electronic scales; telephone apparatus; television sets and television apparatus; video recorders; cables; wireless telephone installations; facsimile machines; sound recording materials; video recorder materials; signal remote control for electrical installations; dynamo apparatus; power apparatus; wire generic components; electrical switching components; electrical adjustments installations; electronic alarms; instruments for mining; batteries; integrated circuit boards; electronic components; wireless measurement instruments; recordsTrade mark: Trade mark no: 987391Priority Date: 3 February 2004Specification: Class 9: Computers; computer peripheral devices; monitors (computer hardware); notebook computers; telephone apparatus; portable telephones; facsimile machines; stored program control telephone exchanges; television apparatus; video compact disc (VCD) players; digital compact disc (DVD) players; computer displays; audio and video system, namely audio and video apparatus, cassette deck, speakers, and parts and fittings thereof, sold as a unit for home use; cameras (photography); electric cables; electric wires; telephone wires; electric converters; electric switches; current rectifiers; electric relays; plugs, sockets and other contacts (electric connections); lighting ballasts; electric voltage stabilizers; low voltage power supplies; alarms; theft prevention installations, electric; batteriesTrade mark: Trade mark no: 1093385Priority Date: 18 March 2005Specification: Class 7: Agricultural machines; typographic machines; electromechanical food preparation machines; electromechanical beverage preparation machines; coffee grinders other than handoperated; electric kitchen machines; dry cleaning machines; electromechanical machines for the chemical industry; mixing machines; elevators (lifts); presses; steam engines; motors for refrigerators; control mechanisms for machines, engines or motors; compressors (machines); pumps (machines); valves (parts of machines); propulsion mechanisms other than for land vehicles; waste disposals; electric shoe polishers; electric food processors; washing machines; dishwashers; vacuum cleaners; hand-held tools, other than hand-operated; generators of electricityClass 11: : Lamps; lighting apparatus and installations; water heaters; gas burners; griddles (kitchen appliances); electric heaters for feeding bottles; electric coffee percolators; electric coffee machines; microwave ovens (cooking apparatus); cooking apparatus and installations; electric cooking utensils; electric kettles; ice machines and apparatus; electronic refrigerating cabinets for wines; ice cream making machines; exhaust fans; electric fans for personal use; electric hair dryers; extractor hoods for kitchens; electric laundry dryers; air purifying apparatus; air humidifiers; hair dryers; heating apparatus; water taps; water pipes for sanitary installations; ornamental fountains; heaters for baths; devices for drinking water; water purification installations; gas lighters; sockets for electric lights; refrigerators; air conditioning apparatus; sterilizers; pocket warmers; hand drying apparatus for washroomsTrade mark: TCLTrade mark no: 2067042Priority Date: 4 July 2019Specification: Class 7: Food preparation machines, electromechanical; juice extractors, electric; ironing machines; dishwashers; kitchen machines, electric; blenders, electric, for household purposes; coffee grinders, other than hand-operated; dry-cleaning machines; washing machines [laundry]; wringing machines for laundry; compressed air machines; compressors for refrigerators; door openers, electric; window openers, electric; machines and apparatus for cleaning electric; vacuum cleaners; curtain drawing devices electrically operated; 3D printers; vending machines; motors, electric, for refrigerators; household bean milk maker; electric openers for rolling doorsClass 9: Data processing apparatus; computers; computer peripheral devices; monitors [computer hardware]; tablet computers; computer hardware; USB flash drives; interactive touch screen terminals; humanoid robots with artificial intelligence; electronic interactive whiteboards; wearable computers; network servers; security tokens [encryption devices]; electronic pocket translators; encoded identification bracelets, magnetic; biometric fingerprint scanners; flash memory card adapters; computer software applications, downloadable; electronic agendas; pedometers; facsimile machines; bathroom scales; electronic notice boards; digital signs; telephone apparatus; video telephones; cellular phones; navigational instruments; intercoms; wearable activity trackers; computer network switches; computer network hubs; antennas; transponders; television apparatus; loudspeakers; cabinets for loudspeakers; horns for loudspeakers; megaphones; audio mixers; monitoring apparatus, other than for medical purposes; audio- and video-receivers; sound transmitting apparatus; sound recording apparatus; sound reproduction apparatus; camcorders; portable media players; electronic book readers; headsets; headphones; microphones; virtual reality headsets; security surveillance robots; wearable video display monitors; personal stereos; audio amplifiers; stereo tuners; audio interfaces; equalizers [audio apparatus]; cameras [photography]; video projectors; audiovisual teaching apparatus; surveying apparatus and instruments; inductors [electricity]; thermometers, not for medical purposes; hygrometers; air analysis apparatus; water meters; gas meters; detectors; lasers, not for medical purposes; diagnostic apparatus, not for medical purposes; optical apparatus and instruments; mirrors [optics]; cables, electric; wires, electric; chips [integrated circuits]; lightemitting diodes [LED]; switches, electric; electric plugs; video screens; touch screens; amplifiers; remote control apparatus; electrical adapters; power adapters; temperature sensors; climate control digital thermostats; ultrasonic sensors; heat regulating apparatus; apparatus and installations for the production of X-rays, not for medical purposes; theft prevention installations, electric; electric door bells; locks, electric; alarms; fire alarms; smoke detectors; electronic access control systems for interlocking doors; peepholes [magnifying lenses] for doors; eyeglasses; batteries, electric; chargers for electric batteries; electrostatic copying machines; mobile phones; radios; computer software applications, downloadable; smartwatches (data processing); smartglasses (data processing); computer application software for cellular phones; face recognition device; data cables; rechargeable batteries; electronic pens [visual display units]; network routers; lightemitting diode [LED] televisions; digital signal processors; in-car telephone handset cradles; electronic advertising displays; apparatus for the recording, transmission, amplification and reproduction of sound; infrared detectors; electricity meters; couplers [data processing equipment]; electric sockets; AC/DC power supplies; converters for electric plugs; sensors [measurement apparatus], other than for medical use; electrical control, testing and monitoring apparatus; electronic access control systems for interlocking doorsClass 11: Lamps; cooking utensils, electric; cooking apparatus and installations; grills [cooking appliances]; gas burners; coffee machines, electric; kettles, electric; microwave ovens [cooking apparatus]; bread-making machines; coffee percolators, electric; coffee roasters; refrigerators; freezers; air-conditioning installations; air-conditioning apparatus; air purifying apparatus and machines; drying apparatus and installations; extractor hoods for kitchens; dehumidifiers for household purposes; electric fans for personal use; fabric steamers; heating apparatus; heating installations; heaters for baths; hand drying apparatus for washrooms; toilets [water-closets]; toilet seats; water purifying apparatus and machines; radiators, electric; food steamers, electric; pressure cookers, electric; wine cellars, electric; laundry dryers, electric; humidifiers; electrical driers; electric bath heaters; water dispensers; sterilized cupboard.Trade mark: TCLTrade mark no: 2103931Priority Date: 11 October 2019Specification: Class 35: Advertising; public relations; business management consultancy; providing business information via a web site; provision of an online marketplace for buyers and sellers of goods and services; marketing; sales promotion for others; procurement services for others [purchasing goods and services for other businesses]; import-export agency services; personnel management consultancy; administrative services for the relocation of businesses; systemization of information into computer databases; book-keepingClass 37: Heating equipment installation and repair; freezing equipment installation and repair; office machines and equipment installation, maintenance and repair; installation and maintenance of medical devices; installation and maintenance of sanitary apparatus; kitchen equipment installation; installation and maintenance of bathing apparatus; installation and maintenance of illuminating apparatus; electric appliance installation and repair; installation and repair of airconditioning apparatus; installation, maintenance and repair of computer hardware; photographic apparatus repair; installation and maintenance of entertainment or sports apparatus; fire alarm installation and repair; telephone installation and repair; burglar alarm installation and repair. Class 42: Technological research; industrial design; cloud computing; platform as a service [PaaS]; conversion of data or documents from physical to electronic media; creating and maintaining web sites for others; electronic data storage; development of computer platforms; computer programming; maintenance of computer software; computer software design; software as a serviceTrade mark: TCL Micro LEDTrade mark no: 2178344Priority Date: 12 October 2020Specification: Class 9: Fluorescent screens; video screens; remote control apparatus; transistors [electronic]; light-emitting diodes [LED]; television apparatus; audio- and video-receivers; portable media players; wearable video display monitors; semi-conductors; optical fibers [light conducting filaments]; mobile telephones; tablet computers; interactive touch screen terminals; electronic interactive whiteboards

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established