Samootin v Shea

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read
CITATION: Samootin v Shea and Ors [2003] NSWSC 171
HEARING DATE(S): 17 March 2003
JUDGMENT DATE:
17 March 2003
JURISDICTION:
Equity Division
JUDGMENT OF: Palmer J
DECISION: Plaintiff's Motion to vacate hearing date dismissed with costs.
CATCHWORDS: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - LITIGANT IN PERSON - VACATION OF TRIAL DATE - Plaintiff (litigant in person) sought vacation of trial date for third time on ground that her medical condition prevented her from conducting her own case - protracted proceedings in this Court and Family Court - property subject to injunction and undertaking pending determination of proceedings - Plaintiff refused medical examination by Defendants and refused to consent to her doctor speaking to Defendants' doctors on ground of invasion of privacy and embarrassment. - HELD: Plaintiff's medical evidence insufficient to support conclusion that Plaintiff was unfit to conduct her trial herself - the interests of justice required the trial to proceed on date fixed. - PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - ABSENCE OF PARTY - Plaintiff filed Notice of Motion to vacate trial date for third time - Motion fixed for hearing - Plaintiff stated that she would not attend hearing due to her medical condition. - HELD: Plaintiff's Notice of Motion would be heard in her absence - insufficient medical evidence to support Plaintiff's refusal to attend.

PARTIES :

Alexandra Samootin - Plaintiff
Christopher George Shea - First Defendant
Peter John Deans - Second Defendant
Loan Design Pty Limited - Third Defendant
Giselle M. Wagner t/a Northern Beaches Legal Service - Fifth Defendant
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 1973/01
COUNSEL: B. Muir (Sol) - Second to Fourth Defendants
J.W.J. Stevenson - Fifth Defendant
SOLICITORS: Brian Muir & Co - Second to Fourth Defendants
Mallesons Stephen Jaques - Fifth Defendant

      1    Before the Court is a contested application by the Plaintiff, Ms Samootin, to vacate the hearing of this matter which has been fixed before me for five days commencing on 24 March 2003. Ms Samootin has appeared for herself from the commencement of these proceedings, but she is not before the Court today. The Second to Fourth Defendants are represented by Mr Muir, solicitor, and the Fifth Defendant is represented by Mr Stevenson of Counsel. The First Defendant has not played any active part in these proceedings for some time and is not represented today. 2    In the extraordinary circumstances to which I shall refer in detail hereunder, I have determined that Ms Samootin’s application should be heard in her absence and that it should be dismissed with costs. In order to explain what may appear otherwise to be a somewhat draconian ruling, it will be necessary to set out something of the tortuous history of these proceedings to date. 3    The proceedings arise from the dissolution of the marriage between Ms Samootin and the First Defendant, Mr Shea. They were married in 1971 and when they were divorced in June 1993 they jointly owned a property at Waterview Street, Mona Vale, which was the matrimonial home. In 1997 the Mona Vale property was sold…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Samootin v Shea and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWSC 171
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Samootin v Shea involved protracted legal proceedings between the parties, with a significant focus on the plaintiff's ability to manage her own case due to a claimed medical condition. The dispute revolved around property matters and had been ongoing in both this Court and the Family Court. The proceedings included an injunction and an undertaking related to the property, which remained in place pending the outcome of the case. The plaintiff, representing herself, sought to vacate the trial date for a third time, arguing that her medical condition prevented her from participating in the trial. Additionally, she refused a medical examination by the defendants and declined to allow her doctor to communicate with the defendants' doctors, citing privacy and embarrassment as reasons.

The legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff's medical condition was sufficient to warrant a further vacation of the trial date and whether the plaintiff could be compelled to attend the hearing of her own motion to vacate in her absence. The court was required to weigh the plaintiff's medical claims against the interests of justice and the need for the proceedings to conclude.

The court found that the plaintiff's medical evidence was not sufficiently compelling to conclude that she was unfit to conduct her own trial. Given the length of the proceedings and the need to move forward in the interest of justice, the court decided that the trial must proceed on the date that had been set. Furthermore, the court determined that the plaintiff's Notice of Motion would be heard despite her absence, as there was insufficient medical evidence to support her refusal to attend. The court held that the interests of justice required the motion to be heard without the plaintiff's presence.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves protracted litigation between Samootin and Shea in both this Court and the Family Court, with the property subject to an injunction and an undertaking pending the determination of the proceedings. Samootin, the Plaintiff, is a litigant in person who has sought to vacate the trial date on three occasions. Her primary ground for the third request to vacate is her medical condition, which she claims prevents her from conducting her own case. Samootin has refused to undergo a medical examination by the Defendants and has also declined to allow her doctor to speak to the Defendants' doctors, citing reasons of privacy and embarrassment. Despite these assertions, Samootin has continued to participate in the legal proceedings, albeit with frequent requests to reschedule the trial date.

This matter has seen multiple interactions with the court due to the Plaintiff's repeated applications to vacate the trial date. Each application has been meticulously considered, with the court assessing the Plaintiff's ability to proceed with the trial. The Plaintiff has not only sought to postpone the trial but also filed a Notice of Motion to vacate the trial date for a third time. When the Motion was fixed for hearing, the Plaintiff indicated that she would not attend due to her medical condition. The court has now determined to hear the Plaintiff's Notice of Motion in her absence, given the insufficient medical evidence to support her refusal to attend.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Plaintiff's medical evidence is sufficient to warrant a conclusion that she is unfit to conduct her own trial.
2. Whether the Plaintiff's refusal to attend the hearing of her Notice of Motion, due to her medical condition, is supported by sufficient medical evidence.

Held
1. The court concluded that the Plaintiff's medical evidence was insufficient to warrant a conclusion that she was unfit to conduct her own trial. Consequently, the trial proceeded on the date fixed.
2. The court held that the Plaintiff's Notice of Motion to vacate the trial date would be heard in her absence as the medical evidence provided was insufficient to support her refusal to attend.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the Plaintiff's medical evidence to determine if it was sufficient to support a conclusion that she was unfit to conduct her own trial. The Plaintiff, who was a litigant in person, had sought to vacate the trial date for the third time, citing her medical condition as the reason. The court noted the protracted nature of the proceedings in both this Court and the Family Court, along with the property that was subject to an injunction and undertaking pending the determination of the proceedings. Despite the Plaintiff's refusal to undergo a medical examination by the Defendants and her refusal to consent to her doctor speaking to the Defendants' doctors on grounds of privacy and embarrassment, the court found the evidence inadequate to conclude she was unfit to proceed. The court emphasised the importance of the interests of justice, ruling that the trial must proceed on the fixed date.

Turning to the second issue, the Plaintiff filed a Notice of Motion to vacate the trial date for the third time, and the motion was fixed for hearing. The Plaintiff indicated that she would not attend the hearing due to her medical condition. The court assessed the medical evidence presented in support of her refusal to attend. Despite the Plaintiff's assertions, the court found that the medical evidence was insufficient to justify her absence. Consequently, the court decided to hear the Notice of Motion in the Plaintiff's absence. The court underscored the need for adequate medical evidence to support such claims, ensuring that the proceedings could continue without undue delay. The binding principle established by the decision is that insufficient medical evidence will not warrant a vacation of trial dates or justify a party's absence from proceedings.