Katich and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

KATICH & ANOR and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2007] WASAT 72



STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALCitation No:[2007] WASAT 72
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
Case No:DR:348/20069 MARCH 2007
Coram:MR J ADDERLEY (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)28/03/07
21Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Application for review upheld and Minister requested for authority to disregard
recommendation of Swan Valley Planning Committee in order to conditionally
approve the subdivision.
B
PDF Version
Parties:MILENKO KATICH
MILA KATICH
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION

Catchwords:

Rural subdivision
Boundary re-alignment
Family succession planning
Swan Valley
Agriculture
Viticulture
Vineyard consolidation
Compatibility of residential lot
Objectives of Swan Valley Planning Act 1995(WA)
Area B
Role of Swan Valley Planning Committee
Viability of vineyard
Water supply
Whether smaller lot constitutes undesirable precedent
Risk to agriculture if vineyard is not consolidated
Relevance of Policy DC3.4
Primacy of Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA)

Legislation:

Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 134(6), s 134(7), s 138(2)
Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA), s 6, s 8
City of Swan Town Planning Scheme No. 9

Case References:

Mirco & Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission [2006] WASAT 165
Notte v Western Australian Planning Commission [2004] WATPAT 167
Nurmi & Ors and Western Australian Planning Commission [2006] WASAT 241


Orders

1. Pursuant to s 134(6) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), the State Administrative Tribunal requests the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure to approve the State Administrative Tribunal disregarding the advice of the Swan Valley Planning Committee recommending the refusal of the amalgamation and re-subdivision of Lots 3 and 50 West Swan Road, Caversham into two lots of 2000 square metres and 1.2569 hectares in area as depicted on the plan of subdivision Reference No 14137 prepared by Statewest Surveying and Planning dated 30 November 2006 in order that the subdivision may be conditionally allowed.,2 The proceedings are adjourned to a further hearing at 10am on 17 May 2007 in order to enable the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure to make a determination in relation to the request in order 1 and to advise the Tribunal in writing or by a representative at the further hearing of her determination.,3 The Executive Officer shall send a copy of these orders and the Tribunal's reasons for decision to the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure.

JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL STREAM : DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES ACT : PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA) CITATION : KATICH & ANOR and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2007] WASAT 72 MEMBER : MR J ADDERLEY (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER) HEARD : 9 MARCH 2007 DELIVERED : 28 MARCH 2007 FILE NO/S : DR 348 of 2006 BETWEEN : MILENKO KATICH
    MILA KATICH
    Applicants

    AND

    WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
    Respondent

Catchwords:

Rural subdivision - Boundary re-alignment - Family succession planning - Swan Valley - Agriculture - Viticulture - Vineyard consolidation - Compatibility of residential lot - Objectives of Swan Valley Planning Act 1995(WA) - Area B -…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Katich and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] WASAT 72
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Katich and Anor initiated legal proceedings against the Western Australian Planning Commission, contesting the Commission's refusal to approve a subdivision plan for their property in the Swan Valley. The applicants sought to amalgamate and re-subdivide two lots into smaller residential lots and a larger vineyard area. The dispute was heard by the State Administrative Tribunal, tasked with reviewing the Planning Commission's decision under the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA).

The central legal issues revolved around the compatibility of the proposed subdivision with the objectives of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) and the role of the Swan Valley Planning Committee in such decisions. The Tribunal had to consider whether the proposed smaller residential lot would set an undesirable precedent and whether the consolidation of the vineyard was necessary for the viability of the agricultural enterprise. Additionally, the Tribunal examined the relevance of Policy DC3.4 and the primacy of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) in guiding the decision-making process.

The Tribunal found that the proposed subdivision aligned with the objectives of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) and that the smaller residential lot would not set an undesirable precedent. The Tribunal also determined that the consolidation of the vineyard was necessary for its viability, particularly in light of water supply considerations. The Tribunal concluded that the Planning Commission's refusal to approve the subdivision was not in accordance with the law, as it did not adequately consider the primacy of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) and the need to balance residential development with the preservation of agricultural land.

The Tribunal ordered that the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure approve the Tribunal's decision to conditionally allow the subdivision, disregarding the Planning Committee's advice. The proceedings were adjourned to allow the Minister to make a determination, with a further hearing scheduled for 17 May 2007. The Tribunal also directed that a copy of the orders and reasons for decision be sent to the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 134(6) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), the State Administrative Tribunal requests the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure to approve the State Administrative Tribunal disregarding the advice of the Swan Valley Planning Committee recommending the refusal of the amalgamation and re-subdivision of Lots 3 and 50 West Swan Road, Caversham into two lots of 2000 square metres and 1.2569 hectares in area as depicted on the plan of subdivision Reference No 14137 prepared by Statewest Surveying and Planning dated 30 November 2006 in order that the subdivision may be conditionally allowed. 2 The proceedings are adjourned to a further hearing at 10am on 17 May 2007 in order to enable the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure to make a determination in relation to the request in order 1 and to advise the Tribunal in writing or by a representative at the further hearing of her determination. 3 The Executive Officer shall send a copy of these orders and the Tribunal's reasons for decision to the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute over the proposed amalgamation and re-subdivision of Lots 3 and 50 on West Swan Road, Caversham. The applicants, Katich and another party, sought to subdivide the lots into two separate properties: one measuring 2000 square metres and the other 1.2569 hectares. This re-subdivision was intended to facilitate family succession planning within the context of rural land use in the Swan Valley, where viticulture and agriculture are significant activities. The area in question falls within the jurisdiction of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) and is classified under Area B, which necessitates the involvement of the Swan Valley Planning Committee in the decision-making process.

The applicants argued that the re-subdivision was necessary to consolidate the vineyard and ensure its viability, particularly in light of water supply considerations. They contended that a smaller lot would set an undesirable precedent and potentially jeopardise the agricultural activities within the region. The applicants also emphasised the importance of adhering to the objectives of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA), which aims to preserve and promote the agricultural and viticultural character of the area. They asserted that Policy DC3.4, which addresses the consolidation of vineyards, supported their case, and that the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) should take precedence in this matter.

In response, the Swan Valley Planning Committee had recommended the refusal of the proposed subdivision, citing concerns about the precedent it might set and the potential risk to agriculture if the vineyard were not consolidated. The applicants sought to overturn this recommendation through the State Administrative Tribunal, which considered the merits of their application and the broader implications for the region's agricultural and viticultural sectors. The Tribunal's decision ultimately hinged on the compatibility of the proposed subdivision with the objectives of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) and the role of the Swan Valley Planning Committee in the planning process.

This matter came before the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT) as an appeal against a decision of the Swan Valley Planning Committee. The applicants, Katich and Anor, sought to amalgamate and re-subdivide Lots 3 and 50 West Swan Road, Caversham, into two lots of 2000 square metres and 1.2569 hectares respectively. The Swan Valley Planning Committee had refused the application, and the applicants appealed this decision to the SAT. Prior to this appeal, the applicants had submitted their proposal to the Swan Valley Planning Committee, which deliberated and issued a refusal decision based on its interpretation of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) and associated policies. The applicants were aggrieved by this decision and thus sought review by the SAT.

In the SAT, the applicants argued that the refusal was erroneous and not in accordance with the objectives and policies of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA). They emphasised the need for the re-subdivision to ensure the viability of their vineyard, the compatibility of the proposed residential lot with the surrounding rural area, and the relevance of Policy DC3.4. They contended that the refusal set an undesirable precedent and risked the long-term sustainability of their agricultural operations. The SAT heard evidence and submissions from both parties and considered the statutory framework and relevant policies governing rural land use and planning in the Swan Valley.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proposed re-subdivision of Lots 3 and 50 West Swan Road, Caversham into two lots of 2000 square metres and 1.2569 hectares in area is compatible with the objectives of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA).
2. Whether the proposed re-subdivision and amalgamation of the vineyard lots constitutes an undesirable precedent for future rural subdivisions in the Swan Valley.
3. Whether the smaller lot of 2000 square metres is sufficient to maintain the viability of the vineyard, considering the water supply and other agricultural requirements.
4. Whether the proposed re-subdivision poses a risk to the agricultural activities in the area if the vineyard is not consolidated.
5. Whether Policy DC3.4 of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) is relevant to the decision regarding the proposed re-subdivision.
6. What is the role of the Swan Valley Planning Committee in the decision-making process regarding the proposed re-subdivision, and does the primacy of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) override the Committee’s advice?

Held
1. The proposed re-subdivision of Lots 3 and 50 West Swan Road, Caversham into two lots is compatible with the objectives of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA). Appeal allowed.
2. The proposed re-subdivision and amalgamation of the vineyard lots does not constitute an undesirable precedent for future rural subdivisions in the Swan Valley. Application dismissed.
3. The smaller lot of 2000 square metres is sufficient to maintain the viability of the vineyard, considering the water supply and other agricultural requirements. Application allowed.
4. The proposed re-subdivision does not pose a risk to the agricultural activities in the area if the vineyard is not consolidated. Application allowed.
5. Policy DC3.4 of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) is relevant to the decision regarding the proposed re-subdivision. Policy considered and applied.
6. The role of the Swan Valley Planning Committee in the decision-making process regarding the proposed re-subdivision is significant, but the primacy of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) overrides the Committee’s advice. Primacy of the Act upheld.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Katich and Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission, the court meticulously examined the compatibility of a proposed re-subdivision of Lots 3 and 50 West Swan Road, Caversham, with the objectives of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA). The court held that the proposed re-subdivision into two lots, one of 2000 square metres and the other of 1.2569 hectares, aligns with the legislative objectives of preserving the rural character of the Swan Valley while accommodating family succession planning. The court underscored the importance of these objectives in ensuring that subdivisions do not unduly fragment the landscape or compromise the viability of agricultural activities.

The court deliberated on whether the proposed re-subdivision and amalgamation of the vineyard lots set an undesirable precedent for future rural subdivisions. It concluded that the specific circumstances of this case, particularly the family succession planning, did not establish a precedent that would undermine the broader objectives of the planning act. The decision was tailored to the unique context of the property, ensuring that it did not broadly affect future rural subdivisions in the area.

Regarding the viability of the smaller lot of 2000 square metres, the court found that it was sufficient to maintain the vineyard. This conclusion was based on the adequacy of the water supply and other agricultural requirements, as supported by expert evidence presented. The court highlighted that the smaller lot could still sustain the vineyard operations, thus upholding the agricultural integrity of the area.

The court also assessed whether the proposed re-subdivision posed a risk to the agricultural activities if the vineyard was not consolidated. It determined that the proposed division did not inherently pose such a risk, as the smaller lot could continue to support vineyard activities without detriment to the surrounding agricultural operations.

The relevance of Policy DC3.4 of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) was scrutinized, with the court finding that this policy did not directly impact the decision regarding the proposed re-subdivision. The policy in question pertained to broader planning considerations that did not specifically address the unique circumstances of this case.

Lastly, the court examined the role of the Swan Valley Planning Committee in the decision-making process. It concluded that while the committee's advice is valuable, the primacy of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) overrides the committee’s recommendation. The court emphasized that its decision was rooted in the statutory objectives and not bound by the committee's advice, ensuring that the legislative intent was given precedence.