Josef Vuzem, Maria Vuzem, Jim Cupkovic, Adrianna Cupkovic, Dusan Cupkovic and Sonia Cupkovic, Mobil Oil Australia Limited, BP Australia Limited and P and C Sutton Investments Pty Ltd v Motor Fuel Licensing Board..

This is an application for judicial review, pursuant to SCR98.01, sought to be prosecuted by persons claiming to be aggrieved by a decision of the Motor Fuel Licensing Appeal Tribunal ("the Tribunal") overturning a refusal to transfer a motor fuel retailing licence to new premises. The applicants hold similar licences in the vicinity of the new premises. The applicants contended that the Tribunal had lacked jurisdiction to hear the appeal and had made errors of law that vitiated its decision. The Court found that the applicants did not have locus standi to bring the proceedings, and even if they did, the application was foredoomed to failure. The Court held that the judicial review process is not concerned with questions of the correctness of decisions made within jurisdiction, and the Tribunal was entitled to come to the conclusions it reached based on the evidence before it. The application was dismissed.