| [2024] FWC 1520 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
John Dlima
v
Receivables People Solutions Pty Ltd, t/a ARL Collect
(U2024/2705)
| DEPUTY PRESIDENT COLMAN | MELBOURNE, 12 JUNE 2024 |
Unfair dismissal application – genuine redundancy – application dismissed
John Dlima has made an application under s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act). He contends that he was unfairly dismissed by Receivables People Solutions Pty Ltd (RPS), which trades as ARL Collect, and seeks reinstatement. RPS submits that the dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy within the meaning of s 389 of the Act and contends that in any event the dismissal was not unfair because his position was not needed and he was dismissed following a fair process.
Mr Dlima was employed as a customer relationship officer (CRO) in the PayPal team of ARL Collect Pty Ltd, an associated entity of RPS, which together with PF Group Holdings Pty Ltd (Panthera Group) and Panthera Finance Pty Ltd (Panthera Finance) carry on the business of debt purchase and recovery. Mr Dlima was covered by the Banking, Finance and Insurance Award 2020 (Award).
Frank Terranova, the group chief financial officer, gave evidence that in the past two financial years the group has sustained losses exceeding 30 million dollars. He said that the group’s financial position was precarious, and that to stay financially viable, it had to reduce operating expenses, including labour costs. To do this, the decision was made to restructure and downsize the companies in the group. On 2 January 2024, he sent an email to the group advising all staff that it would be necessary to reduce the group’s workforce and that some positions would be made redundant. He said that the group then worked through the restructure of each entity one at a time and that ultimately 78 employees were made redundant across the group.
Robert Whelan, general manager, gave evidence that in January 2024 he met with Amy Kayani, human resources officer, to consider how the ARL business, including its PayPal team, could be restructured. On 9 February 2024, he put forward a proposal which contemplated a reduction in the PayPal team from 4.5 full-time equivalent employees (FTEs) to 2. At that time, the team comprised a team leader and 6 CROs, 3 of whom were full-time, including Mr Dlima, as well as two part-time employees and one casual. Mr Whelan considered that there was significant scope for efficiencies to be made in the PayPal team in addition to a reduction in numbers, including dialler speed efficiencies, directing customers to the portal, and reallocating the team leader’s duties to the Echuca team leader. One factor that Mr Whelan took into account was that PayPal had flagged that it would be onboarding an additional debt collection agency, which would reduce business volume. Another was that as of February 2024, referrals had been steadily dropping off for several months. He also considered that, even with the present level of referrals, the team could achieve…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read John Dlima v Receivables People Solutions Pty Ltd, t/a ARL C... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] FWC 1520
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the company no longer required Mr Dlima’s job to be performed by anyone because of changes in the operational requirements of its enterprise. It accepted the evidence of Frank Terranova, the group chief financial officer, who gave evidence that in the past two financial years the group had sustained losses exceeding 30 million dollars. He said that the group’s financial position was precarious and that to stay financially viable, it had to reduce operating expenses, including labour costs. The company complied with its consultation obligations under the Award in relation to the redundancy. It found that it would not have been reasonable in all the circumstances for Mr Dlima to be redeployed within the company or any of its associated entities. The only evidence of any available position or work that Mr Dlima might conceivably have done was the team leader position. The court accepted the evidence of Simon Offord, head of compliance and customer advocacy, that Mr Dlima was not suitable for this role. It was sensible and compelling. The court found that Mr Dlima did not have the required qualifications and experience for the role of resolutions team leader and that reasonable retraining could not have rendered him suitable for the role.
The court found that Mr Dlima’s dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy. But irrespective of this question, it could not identify any unfairness in this dismissal, having regard to section 387 or otherwise. The company did not need Mr Dlima’s role to be undertaken by anyone. Whatever Mr Dlima might think about the matter, the business simply does not need 4.5 FTE CROs in its PayPal team because 2 CROs can do the job perfectly well. And there is no indication of any other work Mr Dlima could reasonably have done. Some 78 employees have been made redundant across the group. Finally, had the dismissal been unfair, which patently it was not, reinstatement would have been entirely inappropriate because Mr Dlima’s position no longer exists and there is no evidence of any available work he could now usefully do. The application is dismissed.