Brookfield v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Brookfield v State of Queensland [2024] QSC 219

PARTIES:

IAN WALTER BROOKFIELD

(plaintiff)

v
STATE OF QUEENSLAND

(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS15087 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

27 September 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

15-19 April 2024

JUDGE:

Cooper J

ORDER:

1.   The amended claim filed on 21 July 2022 is dismissed.

2.   I will hear the parties as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

TORTS – INTERFERENCE WITH THE PERSON – FALSE IMPRISONMENT – LAWFUL JUSTIFICATION – ARREST AND DETENTION AND IMPRISONMENT IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS – where the plaintiff, in pursuing a debt, repeatedly contacted the debtor, as well as his staff, family, and business associates, via text, email, and social media – where the police initially declined the debtor’s request to investigate the plaintiff’s conduct on the basis that it was a civil dispute – where the police subsequently investigated the debtor’s complaint, arrested the plaintiff and charged him with various offences related to his conduct towards the debtor, including breaching bail conditions – where the charges against the plaintiff were subsequently dismissed or dropped – where the plaintiff was arrested pursuant to a warrant and charged for dishonesty offences relating to his alleged forgery of a signature on a contract – where those charges were subsequently dismissed by a magistrate – whether the arrests of the plaintiff were lawful

TORTS – ABUSE OF LEGAL PROCESS – MALICIOUS PROSECUTION – ESSENTIALS OF ACTION – ABSENCE OF REASONABLE AND PROBABLE CAUSE – where the plaintiff’s conduct towards the debtor led to him being arrested for and charged with stalking and using a carriage service to menace, harass or cause offence – where the arresting officer gave evidence that he honestly believed that the available material made it appropriate to charge the plaintiff with the offences – where the plaintiff’s conduct included sending emails and other communications to the debtor, his family members, and his staff accusing the debtor and his family of criminal conduct, insulting them, complaining about their conduct, and creating harassing social media posts – where the plaintiff was also separately investigated for and charged with fraud for taking a deposit payment on a vehicle that was encumbered – where a breach of bail charge was laid based on what one police officer told another regarding the plaintiff attending a courthouse where the complainant was, in contravention of a bail condition – where the material relied on to support charges of forgery, uttering and perjury was said to demonstrate that the plaintiff knew the complainant had not signed the contract but the plaintiff was nevertheless purporting to rely on it in court proceedings – whether it would have been open to a jury to convict the plaintiff of the offences – whether the charging police officers acted without reasonable and probable cause in charging the plaintiff

TORTS – ABUSE OF LEGAL PROCESS – MALICIOUS PROSECUTION – ESSENTIALS OF ACTION – MALICE – GENERALLY – where…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brookfield v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 219
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Brookfield v State of Queensland, the plaintiff, Brookfield, sued the Queensland Police Service (QPS) for various torts arising out of a civil dispute with the debtor, Mergard. Brookfield alleged that the police had unlawfully arrested and detained him, maliciously prosecuted him, and engaged in misfeasance in public office, among other things. The primary legal issues before the court were whether the police's arrests and detentions of Brookfield were lawful, whether the police had acted maliciously in charging Brookfield, and whether the police's conduct constituted misfeasance in public office, among other things.

The court found that although some of the police reports contained factual errors, none of the police's actions could be properly characterised as an invalid or unauthorised act, or as an act of malice. The court held that Brookfield had not established that any conduct by any QPS officer gave rise to a cause of action for misfeasance in public office. The court also rejected Brookfield's claim that the police had perverted the course of justice, finding that there was no evidence to support such a claim. The court found that the police had acted reasonably in charging Brookfield, and that their actions did not amount to intimidation. The court dismissed Brookfield's amended claim in its entirety.

The court ordered that the amended claim filed on 21 July 2022 be dismissed and directed the parties to attend a costs hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The amended claim filed on 21 July 2022 is dismissed.

2. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Brookfield was then released on bail on all four charges. As had been foreshadowed by Officer Self, one of the bail conditions imposed on Mr Brookfield prohibited him from approaching or being within 50 metres of Mr Mergard or Mrs Mergard “unless for the purpose of attending court”.Evidence of charges against Mr Brookfield used in Federal Court proceedings On 26 May 2019, Officer Self sent an email to Ms O’Connell which:(a)informed Ms O’Connell that he would be on leave for a month from the following day;(b)asked if Mr Mergard’s statement could be updated to include the effect that Mr Brookfield’s communications and the civil proceedings were having upon Mr Mergard’s business interests, finances, health and mental state;(c)informed Ms O’Connell of the three offences which Mr Brookfield had been charged with the previous day;(d)notified Ms O’Connell of the bail conditions imposed on Mr Brookfield and said she could report any breach of those bail conditions on the policelink telephone service;(e)set out a summary of facts which the email stated would be “read to the court if and after the defendant is found guilty.” The email also stated that the summary of facts might be edited after plea negotiations. On 5 June 2019, an application by Mr Brookfield to wind up Real Estate Now was heard by Justice Derrington in the Federal Court of Australia. In opposing that application, Real Estate Now relied on Officer Self’s email to Ms O’Connell in support of a submission that the winding up application should be dismissed as an abuse of process. Justice Derrington’s decision dismissing the winding up application contained the following passage:[1]“[45] [Real Estate Now] also sought to support its claim that the winding up application was part of a concerted and orchestrated scheme of intimidation by Mr Brookfield, by adducing evidence of a series of emails, texts and internet posts which Mr Brookfield had sent or uploaded to the internet. [Real Estate Now] also relied on an email from an officer of the Queensland Police Service in relation to charges which have been preferred against Mr Brookfield. The two matters appear to be related. As mentioned above, to the extent to which it is possible to ascertain, the internet posts and emails appear to have been sent or posted in the period between 2015 and 2017. For reasons which are not immediately clear, the Queensland Police appear to have only now sought to charge Mr Brookfield with various offences relating to the misuse of a carriage service and stalking. That said, the correspondence produced might suggest that the charging has occurred as a result of the intervention of the company’s solicitors. On 26 May 2019, a person described as Andrew Self, Detective Acting Senior Sergeant of the Bundaberg Criminal Investigation Branch, sent an email to the solicitors acting for [Real Estate Now] and Mr Mergard. It has Mr Self’s official Queensland Police footer on it. The purpose of the email is not immediately apparent but it has the appearance of a statement purportedly setting out the conduct of the police investigation, the arrest of Mr Brookfield and the bail conditions. Mr Self identifies a number of charges which he says are brought against Mr Brookfield. The statement of the offences are remarkable for the lack of any reference to the dates on which the alleged offences occurred. That is important, as the email of Mr Self was sent only a few days prior to the hearing of this application and, it might seem, to assist [Real Estate Now] and Mr Mergard in this litigation. One must wonder why, if the harassment occurred or at least commenced a number of years ago, the police have only recently arrested Mr Brookfield and why full details of police operations and the manner of the investigation were disclosed as they were. Given the historical practice of police forces in Australia not to disclose their methods of investigation and processes it is a remarkable document indeed. Even disclosing to alleged victims of crime the conduct of investigations and the steps taken to prosecute could not be thought to be common amongst police forces.[46] Given the long history of hostilities between the parties I pay little attention to the unsworn allegations made by Mr Self in his email. Regardless of what the circumstances are in the present case, it would be a matter of great regret to find that members of the police force would involve themselves in assisting particular parties in civil litigation. Not in the least is that it tends to undermine the confidence that the public might have that the police undertake their tasks in an unbiased and dispassionate manner.[47] The arrest of Mr Brookfield shortly before the hearing gives cause for concern. It may well have been coincidental. If, however, there was evidence that it had been arranged for the purposes of this matter, reference to the proper authorities would be required. Fortunately, there is no such evidence.”[1]Brookfield v Real Estate Now Pty Ltd (2019) 137 ACSR 641, 653-654 [45]-[47].Arrest of Mr Brookfield for breach of bail

Decision

Reasons for decision

Although it can be accepted that Officer Bishop’s reports contained some factual errors, Mr Brookfield has not established that anything Officer Bishop did could be properly characterised as an invalid or unauthorised act, or that Officer Bishop acted maliciously. I am not satisfied that any of Officer Bishop’s actions amounted to misfeasance in public office.Conclusion on the claim for misfeasance in public office Mr Brookfield has not established that any conduct by any QPS officer gave rise to a cause of action for misfeasance in public office. That part of Mr Brookfield’s claim must be dismissed.Perverting the course of justice Mr Brookfield’s amended statement of claim identified the following matters as the basis for his claim in respect of conduct which, on his case, perverted the course of justice:(a)Officer Self assisting Mills Oakley in the conduct of civil proceedings in the Federal Court (paragraphs 26, 33 and 131);(b)Officer Self directing Officer Burgess to arrest and charge Mr Brookfield for breach of bail (paragraph 56);(c)Officer Self’s imposition of a bail condition which sought to prevent Mr Brookfield from commencing any further civil proceedings against Mr Mergard and Real Estate Now (paragraphs 67 and 73). Conduct by which a person attempts to pervert the course of justice constitutes a criminal offence.[124][124]Criminal Code, s 140. Mr Brookfield did not identify the source of any private right of action for damages which is available to him in respect of conduct which might fall within the criminal offence of attempting to pervert the course of justice. It might be argued that the claim could be framed as a claim for breach of statutory duty. If that is the way Mr Brookfield sought to frame this aspect of his claim, I would reject it. In Young v Crime and Corruption Commission,[125] McMurdo JA (with whom Fraser and Morrison JJA agreed) said that more than a breach of a duty imposed by a statute is required for the existence of a right of action for damages for such breach. A right of action only exists where a statute imposes a duty for the protection or benefit of a particular class of persons, from which it can been seen that, upon its proper construction, the statute intends to provide a ground of civil liability when the breach of the duty causes injury or damage.[125][2019] QCA 189, [18]. That requirement is not satisfied in respect of this aspect of Mr Brookfield’s claim. As Crow J observed in Dickson v Cubela,[126] the provisions of the Criminal Code do not give rise to any right of action which may form the basis of a claim for breach of statutory duty.[126][2018] QSC 34, [11]. In any event, for the reasons already given, I accept the defendant’s submission that there is no evidence which could support a finding that any of the QPS officers who dealt with Mr Brookfield attempted to pervert the course of justice.Intimidation The elements of the tort of intimidation are:[127](a)the defendant must threaten to use unlawful means to compel the person threatened to obey the defendant’s demand;(b)the person threatened must comply with that demand;(c)the plaintiff must suffer damage as a consequence of that compliance; and(d)the defendant must have acted with the intention of harming the plaintiff.[127]Ballard v Multiplex [2012] NSWSC 426, [88]; Jack Brabham Engines Ltd v Beare [2010] FCA 872, [303].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.